Indeed Allah & His angels send blessings on the Prophet; O People who Believe! Send blessings & abundant salutations upon him.

Monday, September 25, 2023

On September 25, 2023 by Global Fashion in    No comments

Islam could become another. It’s concise (under 200 pages), sympathetic, and clear. Or as clear as a book can be that tries to explain the differences between Umayyads and Abbasids, ulama and mujdadid, Shiis and Sunnis, Sutis known as Whirling Dervishes and Sutis who just sit still and breathe deeply.

Confusion is almost the point. Confronted by Islam in all its dizzying diversity, readers may begin to feel like Whirling Dervishes themselves as old stereotypes suddenly fly from their grasp. Armstrong’s theme is that centuries of conflict between the West and Islam (not to mention centuries of entertainment from Mozart operas to Hollywood movies that feature fiendish Saracens and narrow escapes from cruel sultans) have produced an archetypal Muslim in Western minds. He’s at once intolerant and indolent, despotic and submissive, puritanical and sensual, crafty and primitive, capricious and fatalistic. Above all, he’s a religious fanatic. Any progress in overcoming this image was presumably set back years on Sept. 11 — which is why a book like this is suddenly essential.


In Armstrong’s brisk narrative, the clichés evaporate fast. Islam advocates the enslavement of women? The Prophet Muhammad, as was customary, took numerous wives, but he broke with the harsh treatment of women that prevailed in seventh-century Arabia by giving them considerable respect and freedom. And the Koran — the Islamic scriptures — gave women rights to divorce and inheritance long before Christian Europe did. Jihad? Armstrong says it’s properly translated as ”effort” or ”struggle,” not ”holy war.” And, she adds, the Koran justifies defensive war but ”does not sanctify warfare.” The Arab conquests that created an Islamic empire from Spain to Afghanistan after Muhammad’s death in 632 were not primarily driven by religious motives, the author insists, and the Koran insists ”there shall be no coercion in matters of faith.”


Armstrong doesn’t neglect the dark side of Islamic history, which she notes contains about as many massacres as the dark side of Christian history. But what makes the book so appealing is that it doesn’t reduce Islam to its dark side or any other side. And she finds that Islamic fundamentalism has more in common with other fundamentalisms, including Christian and Jewish, than with Islamic traditions. All, she argues, are modern ideologies born of hatred and fear of modernity — science, individualism, the independence of women. All invent purified versions of the faith that have little to do with authentic origins and practices. Armstrong ascribes the particularly virulent form fundamentalism has taken in the Islamic world to the desperation aroused by the combination of Western secular culture and oppressive Middle Eastern dictatorships. And she points out that Islam’s deepest precepts mix up God and history (and God and politics) more than any other world religion, which can be a formula for fanaticism. But all religions have their demons to overcome, and her history shows that Islam is capable of overcoming its own, even now, when it finds itself with an ungodly number of them.   Islam could become another. It’s concise (under 200 pages), sympathetic, and clear. Or as clear as a book can be that tries to explain the differences between Umayyads and Abbasids, ulama and mujdadid, Shiis and Sunnis, Sutis known as Whirling Dervishes and Sutis who just sit still and breathe deeply.


Confusion is almost the point. Confronted by Islam in all its dizzying diversity, readers may begin to feel like Whirling Dervishes themselves as old stereotypes suddenly fly from their grasp. Armstrong’s theme is that centuries of conflict between the West and Islam (not to mention centuries of entertainment from Mozart operas to Hollywood movies that feature fiendish Saracens and narrow escapes from cruel sultans) have produced an archetypal Muslim in Western minds. He’s at once intolerant and indolent, despotic and submissive, puritanical and sensual, crafty and primitive, capricious and fatalistic. Above all, he’s a religious fanatic. Any progress in overcoming this image was presumably set back years on Sept. 11 — which is why a book like this is suddenly essential.


In Armstrong’s brisk narrative, the clichés evaporate fast. Islam advocates the enslavement of women? The Prophet Muhammad, as was customary, took numerous wives, but he broke with the harsh treatment of women that prevailed in seventh-century Arabia by giving them considerable respect and freedom. And the Koran — the Islamic scriptures — gave women rights to divorce and inheritance long before Christian Europe did. Jihad? Armstrong says it’s properly translated as ”effort” or ”struggle,” not ”holy war.” And, she adds, the Koran justifies defensive war but ”does not sanctify warfare.” The Arab conquests that created an Islamic empire from Spain to Afghanistan after Muhammad’s death in 632 were not primarily driven by religious motives, the author insists, and the Koran insists ”there shall be no coercion in matters of faith.”


Armstrong doesn’t neglect the dark side of Islamic history, which she notes contains about as many massacres as the dark side of Christian history. But what makes the book so appealing is that it doesn’t reduce Islam to its dark side or any other side. And she finds that Islamic fundamentalism has more in common with other fundamentalisms, including Christian and Jewish, than with Islamic traditions. All, she argues, are modern ideologies born of hatred and fear of modernity — science, individualism, the independence of women. All invent purified versions of the faith that have little to do with authentic origins and practices. Armstrong ascribes the particularly virulent form fundamentalism has taken in the Islamic world to the desperation aroused by the combination of Western secular culture and oppressive Middle Eastern dictatorships. And she points out that Islam’s deepest precepts mix up God and history (and God and politics) more than any other world religion, which can be a formula for fanaticism. But all religions have their demons to overcome, and her history shows that Islam is capable of overcoming its own, even now, when it finds itself with an ungodly number of them.

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Global Visa Consultant Lahore

Address: 274, Block F Phase 1 Johar Town, Lahore, Punjab 54000
M: +923 111 762 324
E: globalvisa30@gmail.com
URL: globalvisaconsultant.com
E: info@globalvisaconsultant.com

Recent Comments

Categories

15 Benefits of Reciting Ayatul Kursi (1) 4 Qul (1) 4 Qul Tarjuma ke sath (1) 40 Hadith Collection (1) 40 Rabbana (1) 40 Ya-Rabbana (1) Adhkaar on Friday (1) Ahad Nama (2) Ayat-e-Shifa (1) Ayat-ul-Kursi-Tarjuma ke sath (1) Ayatul Kursi (2) Ayatul Kursi Benefits (1) Beautiful Dhikr (1) Benefits & Advantages of Ayatul Kursi According To Hadees (1) Benefits And Power of Reciting 4 Qul of Quran (1) benefits of Ahad Nama (1) Benefits of Darood e Akbar (1) Benefits of Darood Sharif (1) Benefits of Dua Mughni (1) Benefits of Dua Suryani (1) Benefits of Dua-e-Hajat (1) Benefits of Dua-e-Jamilah (1) Benefits of Durood-e-Taaj (1) Benefits of Nad-e-Ali (1) Benefits of Ramadhan Fasting (1) Benefits of Surah Ar-Rahman (1) Benefits of Surah Yasin (1) Black Magic Cure in Islam (1) Charon Qul (1) Cure of Magic (1) Cure with Manzil (1) Darood e Akbar (1) Darood e Akbar Benefits (1) Darood e Akbar in Islam (1) Darood Mustaghas (1) Dua e Manzil (1) Dua Mughni (1) Dua Qadah Muazzam (1) Dua Qufal Six (1) Dua Saifi Benefits (1) Dua Suryani (1) Dua-e-Aman (1) Dua-e-Hajat (2) Dua-e-Hajat Benefits (1) Dua-e-Jamilah (1) Dua-e-Kanoot (1) Durood Akseer-e-Azam (1) Durood Kibrit Ahmar (1) Durood Lakhi (1) Durood Muqaddas (1) Durood-e-Ibrahimi (1) Durood-e-Taaj (1) Durood-e-Taaj Benefits (1) Durood-e-Tanjeena (1) Eman Mufassil (1) Eman Mujamal (1) Heart of Quran Surah Yasin (1) History of islam (1) Hizbul Bahr Benefits (1) Introduction to Methodology for Study of the Quran (1) Istikhara (1) Manzil (1) Manzil Dua (1) Manzil Dua Benefits (1) Manzil Dua Cure (1) Manzil Dua in Islam (1) Manzil Dua Islam (1) Most Powerful Darood e Akbar (1) Most Powerful Durood-e-Taaj (1) Nad-e-Ali (1) Nad-e-Ali Benefits (1) Nazar e Bad ka ilaj (1) Questions about Black Stone (1) Qul Al-Falaq (1) Qul Al-Ikhlas (1) Qul Al-Kafirun (1) Qul An-Nas (1) Qurani Surah Benefits (1) Ramadhan Khulasa-e-Quran (1) Salatul Hajat (1) Squandering and Miserliness (1) Surah Yaseen tarjuma ke sath (1) Surah Yasin Benefits (2) Surat Al-Falaq (1) Surat Al-Fatiha (1) Surat Al-Ikhlas (1) Surat Al-Kafirun (1) Surat An-Nas (1) Syed-ul-istighfar (1) Tangdasti Door Karne ka Wazifa (1) The Miracles of Islam (1) The Prayer Of Need (1) The Punishment of Being Sinful (1) Virtues of Fasting in the Summer Taken from: Ibn Rajab al-Hanbalī’s “Latā’if Maʿārif” (1) Virtues of reading Surah Al-Muzzammil (1) Wazaif e Ghawsia (1) Wazaif of Week (1) What is Wudu (1) Ya Salamo ka Wazifa (1)